This translation of Dissoi Logoi is from T.M. Robinson’s Contrasting Arguments: An Edition of the Dissoi Logoi. Arno Press, New York: The original text. Dissoi Logoi or Dialexeis. Author(s): Rosamond Kent Sprague. Reviewed work(s ). Source: Mind, New Series, Vol. 77, No. (Apr., ), pp. 8 Feb Dissoi Logoi Sections opposing arguments Two abstract terms Good and bad Seemly and shameful Essentially the same: Situational.
|Published (Last):||2 July 2013|
|PDF File Size:||10.76 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.8 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Export a Text file For BibTex. This bothered me, so dissoi logoi he said something, I said the opposite. Retrieved 16 Dissoi logoi Things both exist and do not exist The sane and insane do and say the same things The wise are dissoi logoi demented, and the demented are not wise Who speaks at the right lohoi Yes, I think, and no.
Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. Some men hate people and will destroy them given the chance. Journals that are no longer published or that have been combined with another title. So he must know everything.
The Protagoras ‘s dramatic dissoi logoi are conventionally dated dissoi logoi between and BC, so either one of the authors made a mistake in listing the genealogy of Polyclitus, or the Dissoi Logoi was written before Polyclitus had another son, thus dating it to before the s BC.
It is not, however, a standard or typical subject.
Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here Terms Related to the Moving Wall Dissoi logoi walls: The American Journal of Philology 1: Sometimes, like boxers circling eachother, we would switch dissoi logoi and suddenly I was arging for hippos and indoor games and Dave was arguing for lions and outdoor games.
If he said that hippos were more dangerous than lions, then I had to prove that lions were more dangerous than hippos. And as dissoi logoi bit of a tangent, the dissoi logoi of education comes up explicitly at the end of the tract, where the question is asked whether wisdom and moral excellence can be taught. Protagoras stated that every argument had two contradicting sides, both of which could be argued. Get Started Already have an account?
Good or bad dissoi logoi, or Good for some and bad for others, or Good at one time and lpgoi at another time for same person If one act is both good and evil, is it good and evil to the same person? As disoi mentioned, the Dissoi Logoi’s attempt to argue dissoi logoi issue from both sides dissoi logoi reminiscent of Plato’s Protagoraswhich was presumably written after the Dissoi Logoi.
He comes to this conclusion through a question, “What if a Greek child is born in Greece dissoi logoi immediately sent to live in Persia? In ancient Greece, students of rhetoric would be asked to speak and write for both sides of a controversy.
Dissoi Logoi | Philosophy Summaries
For instance, in the very first chapter, the author states “some say that what is good and what is bad are two different things, others that pogoi are the same thing. A podcast for beginners and insiders about the people, dissoi logoi and movements that have defined the history of dissoi logoi.
Things exist and do not in respects, in some ways. The composition date of the work is unknown. What cannot be denied is the confounding nature with which the Dissoi Logoi conveys its message. Characteristic of the same man and same art to be able to: If he can converse in question and answers, then he can give answers on any subject. This method works great for school kids all learning together and you can logki this practice in speech and debate classes even today.
While this is most probably true, it is by no means sure, because there are other instances of Spartan victory over Athens which add uncertainty to this dissoi logoi, such as the Battle of Tanagra in BC. Dissoi logoi the philosophical perspective sees dissoi logoi as an exercise for coming at a dissoi logoi truth.
disssoi The other way to practice dissoi logoi is to do it all yourself. Dissoi logoi children independently begin to speak Phrygianwhich is then dissooi to be the first language of man. One possible dissoi logoi to date the work is its mention of the offspring of Polyclitus, a well known Greek sculptor.
Skilled denoting learned and not novice. Thus the Dissoi Logoi are generally dated to between the 5th and early 4th centuries BC. On whether wisdom and dissoi logoi excellence are teachable Cannot proof: He says that people must be persuaded to one side or the other in order to act, and this is accomplished through dissoi logoi.
TEACHING VIRTUE: THE CONTRASTING ARGUMENTS “(DISSOI LOGOI)” OF ANTIQUITY
Dissoi Dissli considers that rhetoric can be situational. For example, if the current year is and a journal has a 5 year moving wall, articles from the year are dissoi logoi. If he knows the truth of things then he knows everything. It was first published by Stephanus inas an appendix to his edition of Diogenes Laertius, and it is found here divided into five chapters.
A dissoi logoi parallel can be drawn between the thoughts of Protagoras as recounted by Plato, and the rhetorical methods used in the Dissoi Logoi.